Donohoe, McGregor and more,
and "The Connell"

Contemporary pride in place is important but in a country as ancient as ours it is just one element with historical self-esteem arguably just as salient. And that is as true of football as it is more generally. Scotland, indeed individual not just cities but towns and villages within the country having been the source of players, officials and administrators, who have been pivotal in the creation of the global game. Remember the not-unlikely probability of "No Scots, no Soccer", certainly as we know it. 

And it is something that the good folk of Busby in Renfrewshire have clearly grasped, albeit so far uniquely. As a reflection, although far from a mirror-image, of the golden statue in Bangu in Brazil of Tommy Donohoe, one of their own but also taker of the game to the country that made it "beautiful", a bust was erected in the village for all locally to be reminded of his feat of feet. 

However, it remains a lone example, albeit at former Glenbuck there is a plaque mainly and a little myopically to Bill Shankly, and this despite numerous possibilities for repetition of the concept elsewhere. Uruguay's John Harley was born and raised in Cathcart, Spain's William Alexander Mackay in Lybster in Caithness, Chile's David Scott and Andrew Gemmill in The Borders and Moray respectively. And they are not alone. Moreover, again amongst others, a plinthed miniature in Braco of the Villa Park McGregor statue and in Bellshill of Old Trafford's one of Matt Busby might not go amiss. Nor would a copy in Paisley of the bust of Huelva's Charles Adam or replicas in Kirkcaldy and Dumbarton, in painting or more solidly, of the mural portraits in London of Arsenal's David Dankin and in Prague of Celtic's, Scotland's and Slavia's Jake Madden.      

Yet, whilst existing recognition in physical form of the above might be capable of Scottish replication, there are many still, such as Argentina's Alex Watson Hutton, who are of parallel importance but for whom, even in their adopted country, never mind their homeland and for whatever reasons, there is nothing comparable. But there are alternatives. As this is written the musical and filmic awards' season has come round again, each in its own way largely an annual refection of achievement that is in most cases completely ephemeral. Yet film and music still do reserve a little for the longer term and in the form of "lifetime" awards, physical and now on-line. Indeed, the first to receive the American version of just such an honour, the "Lifetime Oscar" was Charlie Chaplin, who was, of course, not just an ex-pat but a two-fold Diasporan. He was born an Englishman, who made his name on the other side of the Atlantic, living there until 1952 and then staying in Switzerland until his death by Vevey in 1977. However, quite naturally he is also remembered at home. Chaplin was the seventh to receive the British BAFTA life-time equivalent.    

And for football there are Oscar equivalents, the Halls of Fame. The USA has one, many of the inductees our countrymen, Australia also. Scotland had one too. One hundred and twenty-two were admitted between 2004 and 2019. Then it ceased. Quite why is unclear. But even then for Scots football, the Scottish football taken by Scots elsewhere, the equivalent of the BAFTA-award to English Chaplin for his achievements in American Hollywood, there was almost nothing and never had been. The few, who had made at least a part of their reputations abroad, did so to some extent as players but otherwise as managers and not beyond England. There was and still is no Scottish place of recognition for McGregor, the administrator, for Watson Hutton, regarded in Argentina as the "Father" of its game, for the coach Madden and their like, something we at the SFHG now seek to correct.    

And to do so we look to the "Oscar" as inspiration. The most widely believed reason for the name is that a librarian way back when at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences on first seeing the statuette said it reminded her of her Uncle Oscar. True or false it does not matter. But what it does mean is that we can choose a name of seemingly similar insignificance. Moreover, our Scots footballing "award" needs no physical embodiment. It can be in virtual form therefore costing little except commitment and a small amount of effort. Indeed, all that is really required is a name.  

But we can do better than just that and to do so suggest a figure you might never have heard of but has a background story that has been seriously unsung. For without him, the man in question, the unrepentant enthusiast, who won representative but never quite international honours, both the Scottish and Scots games might not exist. 

The proposal is for the awarding of the "Connell", named for John Burns Connell. A man, of whom we have no visual record - no sketch, no photograph - but know the following. He was born in 1846 in Doune, just north of Stirling but another Perthshire boy. He was raised on a farm in nearby Port of Menteith and there he played not foot-ball, or football and certainly not soccer or rugby but the ancient village- and town-sport of "fitba". In fact so taken was he with the game that when he came to Glasgow to find work in 1862 he brought "a ba'" with him, the first to do so, it is said. And that really is the key to this whole, very-Scottish tale, which he personally, in a posthumously-published article in The Daily Record in 1933, three years after his death in 1930 in his adopted city, would recount much better than anyone . Read the piece below in full, another example of the tireless detective-work of the inestimable Andy Mitchell, and you have both his story and a charming encapsulation of the early days of our "beautiful game". 

The key points are first that John Connell arrived in Glasgow aged just sixteen or seventeen and from elsewhere we know that for fifty years he found work in the drapery trade and in warehousing. This is important because not just was William McGregor, coincidently or not, a draper to trade in Birmingham, in Glasgow a remarkable number of the pioneers of the early game as organisers and players were employed in the same trades.    

Then there is the assertion, and who could gainsay it, that the ball he brought with him was the first to be seen in the city and also that the involvement of money was introduced into the game very early on. Connell's ball was made available for the pre-club, ad-hoc encounters of the era but clearly only on payment of a fee to the man himself. And players, who joined in with those same games, also had to make a payment, albeit it is unclear, other than the ball, for what it was needed or to whom it went.   

Then there was John Connell as a participant himself in the evolving still foot-ball and football scene. This was not the Association game. He not only supplied the vital and not oval but round facilitator of the game, he clearly both played and organised. Off-field he was first involved in the formation of Thistle, whether club or just team is unclear, but it was made up of boys like him, who had also come to the city from the Callander area. In 1868 it played also newly-formed Queen's Park with 20-a-side. Then there were three seasons with the 105th Glasgow Highlanders' Volunteers Regiment before in 1869 the formation, again by the man himself and with him also as captain, of the once more Perthshire-sourced Drummond club. It too would play Queen's Park, this time in 1870 and 18-a-side. 

However, Drummond appears to have lasted little more than a season, after which Connell seems to have had a quiet year before remerging, now aged twenty-seven or twenty-eight, as a member of Eastern, formed in 1872 specifically as an "Association" club. In doing so he had made, in fact he was the embodiment of the transition from "fitba" to "soccer", now recorded as a powerful back (seemingly right-sided), who kicked well but was sometimes "nervous", perhaps meaning in today's language hesitant. And as such he would in 1875 be selected for Glasgow against Sheffield, played at Hamilton Crescent, said to have been watched by 10,000, and a 2-0 home win, plus that same year unsuccessfully taking part in the trial for the national team to face England. But then to succeed he would have had to displace the captain, Joe Taylor. And he, now a shipping clerk, that same year would also marry in the city, his bride Louise Barth, a German-born lady's maid, with whom he would have two children. 

And it seems at this point that John Connell, now thirty, stepped away from the game he had in a single decade done so much to enable, taking Scotland from having little or no involvement to it being its foremost exponent. 1875 had Scotland defeat England for the first time, the start of a run of thirteen games with just one blip. Moreover, he had done it with seemingly little recognition at the time, something which also epitomises and exemplifies the same passion shown by his successors and fellow-country-men in taking the game he had in large part made possible from his start in Glasgow, or is it Perthshire, to the rest Scotland, to England and, indeed, globally.               

Back to the SFHG Home page

QR Code

© Copyright 2022-2025. All rights reserved/Todos los derechos reservados.

Any use of material created by the SFHG for this web-site will be subject to an agreed donation or donations to an SFHG appeal/Cualquier uso del material creado por SFHG para este sitio web estará sujeto a una donación acordada o donaciones a una apelación de SFHG.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.