It is a bold claim to suggest that, of all the pioneers of football in the years that would propel it towards becoming the world’s favourite sport, the most colourful was a female aristocrat from the Scottish Borders – Lady Florence Dixie. Yet even a brief scan of her background reveals an extraordinary - and often harrowing series of events – which make for a compelling tale.
She was born Florence Douglas in 1855 and her father was Archibald Douglas, the 8th Marquis of Queensberry. Her eldest brother, John, became the 9th Marquis and sponsored the Queensberry Rules of boxing – notably the wearing of gloves, rounds of three minutes in length and a knockout count of 10 seconds - which are observed to this day.
John was also a keen footballer and formed his own team – named Kinmount after the Queensberry family home in Dumfries and Galloway – and captained the side against local rivals Annan in games in 1868. Annan wore red caps and Kinmount wore blue. It seems likely that this was Florence’s first exposure to the sport she later championed for women players.
She had a sister, Lady Gertrude and two other older brothers, the Reverend Lord Archibald and Lord Francis. Florence also had a twin named James Edward Sholto Douglas, whom she idolised. As the boxing and football examples show, the Queensbury family had a keen interest in sport and physical accomplishments, with Florence – who was only five feet (1.5m) tall - dubbed a ‘tomboy’ for her enjoyment of swimming, riding and hunting and competing with her male siblings.
Tragedy, however, also played a powerful role in their story. In 1858, Archibald, the 8th Marquis, died in what was said to be a shooting accident, but it was widely believed that he had taken his own life.
In 1865 Francis, aged 18, was part of a group of seven climbers who staged the first successful ascent of the Matterhorn. On the way back, however, four of the group who were linked by a rope, including Francis, plunged 4000 feet (1400m) to their deaths on the Matterhorn Glacier. Francis’s body was never found.
On the 40th anniversary of the accident, Florence wrote an open letter to the many Alpinists who visited the mountain, pleading with them to look out for Francis’s remains. By the 150th anniversary in 2015, over 500 climbers had been killed on the Matterhorn slopes – but Francis’s body has never been located.
Florence was to lose another brother, her adored twin, James, in equally grim circumstances. James began to suffer from intense depressions and on May 5, 1891, in the North Western Hotel at Euston Station, he killed himself by slashing his throat.
Then, in 1895, the family was involved in a notorious scandal when James, the footballing 9th Marquis, discovered that his son, Alfred, was having an affair with the Irish playwright, Oscar Wilde. James denounced Wilde publicly as a homosexual, a status which was illegal at that time. Wilde sued James for criminal libel but lost, leading to his own prosecution and a sentence of two years’ hard labour in Reading Jail.
The scandal still reverberated 80 years later, when the then Poet Laureate, John Betjeman, released an album of his verse, which he read to the music of Jim Parker. One of the tracks, well worth a listen, is ‘The Arrest Of Oscar Wilde At The Cadogan Hotel’.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NyUkeiw8P50
This, then, was the melodramatic background from which Florence emerged, but she extended it at the age of 19 in 1875 by marriage to Sir Alexander Beaumont Churchill Dixie who, at 6ft 3ins (1.88m) towered over her, although she was said to rule him ‘with a rod of iron’.
He was known to friends as Lord ABCD or, more commonly, ‘Beau’ Dixie which, in a later era would have been a perfect name for a Country and Western singer, all the more so because unlike the subject of Kenny Rogers’ classic song, ‘The Gambler’, Florence’s husband didn’t ‘know when to hold ‘em or when to fold ‘em.’
As a consequence of Beau’s gambling addiction, he squandered his annual income of £10,000 – worth around £1.1 million at today’s values – and was forced to sell his ancestral home and estate at Bosworth in Leicestershire. The couple moved to Florence’s home turf of Kinmount in 1885.
By then, women’s football had become a public spectacle, although in somewhat chaotic fashion. The first women’s match on record was supposedly between Scotland and England at Edinburgh’s Easter Road on May 7, 1881. The Scots won 3-0 in front of around 1000 spectators. However, the numbers were apparently made up by actors who treated the occasion as something of a theatrical performance – unsurprisingly, because the game had been organised by the Edinburgh-born theatrical agent, Alec Gordon.
In that regard, the women’s game was only following in the footsteps of the men’s equivalent because in 1868, when the Football Association had staged two games in London which were billed as ‘England v Scotland’, the tartan ranks were made up wholly of players who lived in the capital and some whose names were described as ‘mostly’ sounding Scottish.
In fact, the connection between the thespian world and women’s football continued throughout the 1880s and 1890s with sides such as Madam Kenney’s Famous Edinburgh Team, the Grimsby Town Ladies, and Carl’s Original French Footballers playing matches to raise funds for associated theatres. Madam Kenney’s players beat the Grimsby Ladies 1-0 on St George’s Day, 1887 at the Thornes football field in Wakefield.
It should not be any surprise that women’s game took longer to coalesce than the male version, a situation which reflected the social mores of late Victorian Britain. Tennis, for example, lent itself to women’s participation as a non-contact sport widely played in the gardens of the middle and upper classes.
Even so, the All England Club initially refused to include a women’s singles event until 1884 and even then permitted it to be played only after the men’s competition had been concluded. Men’s football, meanwhile, was emerging from a background of school sport which was long-established and essentially only required to be codified, which occurred when the game divided into soccer and rugby versions.
Moreover, physical contact sports were regarded widely as ‘not lady-like’ and the participation of most married women of the time was subject to the veto or approval of their husbands or wider families. These constraints were never likely to have troubled Florence who, in 1878, when her youngest son was only two months old, left him behind and set off with her husband – and in a group in which she was the only female – to explore Patagonia.
She chose Patagonia because few Europeans had ever visited the country and she wrote a travel book about the expedition, in which she portrayed herself as the principal figure of the group. Florence also returned with a jaguar, which she named Affums and kept as a pet until it had to be confined in a zoo because of its habit of eating live deer.
Florence continued to produce travel writing throughout the 1880s and she was also the author of two children’s books with strong and adventurous girls as the protagonists. She wrote articles for Vanity Fair, in which she supported Home Rule for Scotland and Ireland and was a forceful proponent of women’s suffrage.
In 1895, the British Ladies’ Football Club was founded by Nettie Honeyball, an elusive figure whose real name may have been Mary Hutson. Either way, her aim was to establish the women’s game throughout the UK as an equivalent of the male version.
In February 1895 Honeyball told The Sketch: "There is nothing of the farcical nature about the British Ladies' Football Club. I founded the association late last year, with the fixed resolve of proving to the world that women are not the 'ornamental and useless' creatures men have pictured.
“I must confess, my convictions on all matters, where the sexes are so widely divided, are all on the side of emancipation and I look forward to the time when ladies may sit in Parliament and have a voice in the direction of affairs, especially those which concern them most."
The Sketch (above) had already demonstrated its satirical view of what women’s football would present as a sporting spectacle.
Nettie turned to Florence Dixie for formidable support, with the proposal that Florence should become president of the British Ladies’ Football Club. Florence agreed and in March 1895 the British Ladies’ side played their first match – billed as North of the Thames v South at the Nightingale Lane ground in London’s Crouch End in front of a crowd said to number almost 10,000.
The standard of football was ridiculed by some critics but, in April 1895, Florence laid out her prospectus for the women’s game in the Pall Mall Gazette:
“There is no reason why football should not be played by women, and played well too, provided they dress rationally and relegate to limbo the straight-jacket attire in which fashion delights to clothe them.
“For women to attempt any kind of free movement in fashion's dress means the making of themselves ridiculous, even as men would so make themselves, did they play cricket or football arrayed in skirts and their attendant flummeries.
“I cannot conceive a game more calculated to improve the physique of women than that of football. I refer, of course, to the Association game, which to my mind is the only legitimate representation of this most excellent sport, for I have never been able to see any justification of the word football as applied to the Rugby method of play, which would be better represented by the appellation' harum-scarum scrummage.'
“In Association football a player must be light and swift of foot, agile, wiry, and in good condition - and are not these physical requisites just the very characteristics of good health most to be desired for women?
“To lack them is a misfortune, to attain them an ambition - which all lacking them should have - and certainly football is the surest way of securing them.
“In that school of the future, which, looking ahead, I see arising on the golden hilltops of progress above the mist of prejudice, football will be considered as natural a game for girls as for boys, as will also cricket, athletics, and all national games, in pursuit of which the hideous fashions which crush women with their barbarous and unnatural rule will receive their severest checks and final dethronement.
“It was, therefore, with pleasure, that I accepted the presidency of the British Ladies' Football Club when I was approached and asked to do so. I stipulated of course, that if my name was to be associated therewith, the principle of the club must coincide with my publicly expressed ideas and well-known advocacy of rational dress for women.
“The members of the club do not play in fashion's dress, but in knickers and blouses. They actually allow the calves of their legs to be seen and wear caps and football boots.
“Terrible is it not? ' Quite too shocking!' as an old society dame remarked to me with a shudder, adding squeakily, ' And I certainly should never allow dear Mynie to so demean herself!
“I looked at her and 'dear Mynie,' whom she was chaperoning to a ball, and said nothing, though I thought a good deal.
“And amidst my thoughts I wondered which looked most decent, my lithe, agile football teams, in their dark blue nickers and cardinal and pale blue blouses, and this old slave of fashion and her unnaturally attired charge, with their naked shoulders and arms, pinched in waists, high-heeled shoes, and grotesque balloon-like shoulders hunched and blown out for all the world like huge tumours? I could only come to one conclusion, and that one may be readily guessed.
“If the British public will only give encouragement to the idea, which is now being put into practice, of football for women, it would soon take a firm hold and become an approved custom. I am in hopes that the British Ladies' Football Club will be able to furnish teams to travel about the country and endeavour to popularise the sport by playing some matches in different localities, which a little encouragement of a practical character will enable them to do.
“Let women, therefore, go in for this most excellent game, and earn for themselves that improved physique which will not only improve their appearance, but their health as well, and act as an incentive to the rising generation to go and do likewise.
“‘Hunting,' said Mr Jorrocks, ' is the sport of kings, the image of war.’ 'Football,' says the President of the British Ladies' Football Club, is the sport for women, the pastime of all others which will ensure health, and assist in destroying that hydra-headed monster, the present dress of women.'
“May it live and prosper is my fervent hope and wish.”
The British Ladies’ Football Club undertook a tour of Britain to generate support for their cause and on April 30 they played staged a Reds v Blues match at St Mirren’s home in Paisley. The Reds won 3-0 before what one reporter described as a ‘contemptuously good-natured’ crowd numbering around 5000.
The following day their offering was a North v South contest at East Stirlingshire’s home, Murchiston Park in Falkirk, where the South won 2-1. On the third game in as many days, Edinburgh was host as a crowd of 7000 saw Reds beat the Blues 1-0 at Logie Green, the home ground of St Bernard's FC.
Glasgow got its turn when the Ladies were seen at Cowlairs’ Springvale Park ground, where around 5,000 spectators saw the Blues win 2-1.
The size of the crowds was encouraging, although many of the onlookers were attracted by the novelty of the spectacle. Florence saw enough to believe that the women’s game was a viable entity in its own right but, although the next 20 years saw a burgeoning of female sides in factories – especially during the First World War – it suffered from a backlash by the governing bodies.
In 1921 the Football Association announced a ban on the women’s game from being played at professional grounds and pitches of clubs affiliated to the FA. They stated that “the game of football is quite unsuitable for females and ought not to be encouraged.”
The SFA followed suit in 1921 and in 1949 banned affiliated clubs from allowing women players to use facilities, a state of affairs which was not remedied until the 1970s. That was also the decade when the UK saw Margaret Thatcher become its first woman Prime Minister.
As it happens, a century previously, Florence Dixie had predicted that there would be a female PM by 1999. It would have astonished this indomitable pioneer of the women’s game to learn that the all-male FA and SFA councils would marginalise her sport for so long.
In the end, though, Florence Dixie was proven correct in her belief that women could and should play the only game which she claimed could justify the name of football.
After a lifetime of dedicating herself to social issues, politics, culture and, of course, women’s football, Florence died from diphtheria aged 50, in November 1905, an event thought so notable that it was reported by the New York Times. She was laid to rest alongside her twin brother in the burial ground at Kinmount House, which is now a wedding and conference venue – though few guests are likely to be familiar with the story of Florence’s extraordinary history and her advocacy of the right of women to play the world’s most popular game on the same terms as men.
By Roddy Forsyth
________________________________
Back to SFHGHome page
© Copyright. All rights reserved/Todos los derechos reservados.
Any use of material created by the SFHG for this web-site will be subject to an agreed donation or donations to an SFHG appeal/Cualquier uso del material creado por SFHG para este sitio web estará sujeto a una donación acordada o donaciones a una apelación de SFHG.
We need your consent to load the translations
We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.